The European Court of Human Rights (ECtHR) has banned a Romanian lawyer from appearing before it for two years after judges found that a submission contained “numerous” AI-generated errors.
The lawyer had been acting as one of two representatives in an application to the court.
The judges dealing with the case found that the observations that the lawyer had submitted contained “numerous errors” concerning the court’s case law.
These included the citation of non-existent, or ‘hallucinated’, cases, the citation of fictitious paragraphs in genuine judgments and decisions of the court, and the citation of existing case-law that was irrelevant to the propositions advanced or that “plainly contradicted” the submissions they were intended to support.
The lawyer acknowledged that she had used AI tools to draft the observations and described the mistakes as “inaccuracies” and “citation errors”.
The judges, however, found that her submissions contained “a pattern of numerous, repeated, substantive errors, rather than isolated citation mistakes”.
They concluded that her conduct fell short of the professional and ethical duties imposed by the court.
The chamber said that it had considered the lawyer’s admission that she had not sufficiently checked all the case law she had cited, concluding that this was “an understatement”.
The judges found that her conduct had also affected the administration of justice, with the court having to spend time verifying her observations and initiating proceedings under the ECtHR’s Rule 44D.
They decided that her conduct met the ‘exceptional circumstances’ threshold for exclusion set out under the rules.
The judges’ proposal for a two-year ban from representing applicants was approved by the court’s president.