An adviser to the EU’s highest court has said that a social-media network cannot be described as ‘free’ if users are required to provide personal data for commercial use.
Advocate General Laila Medina was providing an opinion to the EU’s Court of Justice (CJEU) on a question referred to it by Germany’s federal court.
The question arose from a case taken by a German consumer-protection group, Bundesverband der Verbraucherzentralen und Verbraucherverbände, against Facebook’s display of the statement ‘Facebook is and remains free’ on the network’s registration page in February 2015.
The German courts dismissed the action, but the consumer group appealed to Germany’s higher court.
In her opinion, Medina proposes that the CJEU rule that the disclosure of personal data and consent to their commercial use constitute a form of payment under the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive.
The advocate general noted that the wording of the directive, which prohibits describing a product or service as ‘free’ where consumers must pay for it, does not necessarily limit payment to money.
She added that the CJEU had already recognised that payment for a commercial practice might take forms other than money, provided that it had economic value and that there was a definite link between that consideration and the commercial practice concerned.
“Personal data disclosed by users, together with their consent to their commercial exploitation, have economic value for the operator of a social network,” Medina’s opinion stated.
“They enable the operator to generate advertising revenue and finance the service. The fact that users retain their data does not prevent their commercial use from constituting payment,” she added.
The advocate general noted that other EU legislation recognised business models in which consumers obtained digital services in exchange for personal data, rather than money.
She added that limiting payment to money would undermine consumer protection, particularly in the digital economy, where users might be unaware of the economic value of their data or the extent of their exploitation for advertising.
Medina rejected an argument put forward by Facebook’s owner Meta that her interpretation of the Unfair Commercial Practices Directive restricted the freedom to conduct a business or provide services.
“Businesses remain free to offer services in exchange for personal data, but cannot describe them as ‘free’ where such consideration is required,” she concluded.
An advocate general’s opinion is not binding on the court, which will give its judgment in the case at a later date.