Unthinking flunkey

16 Nov 2026 mental capacity Print

Unthinking flunkey

As a solicitor on the Decision Support Service’s independent panel, where does your responsibility as a solicitor begin – and end? Niall Farrell and Maria Dillon ask whether it’s time to question ‘the role of the unthinking flunkey’

To borrow a phrase from a 2016 judgment of Mr Justice Barrett (Carty & others v Mr H), is it time to question “the role of the unthinking flunkey”?

The State may have repealed the Lunacy Regulation (Ireland) Act 1871, but Victorian legislation continues to have relevance in day-to-day legal practice, particularly for practising solicitors who have been appointed decision-making representatives.

The Assisted Decision-Making (Capacity) Act 2015 (as amended) does not define the role of decision-making representative, but one can only be appointed a decision-making representative by order of either the High Court (when a relevant person is discharged from wardship) or by the Circuit Court (on foot of appropriate declarations).

It was also essential for every solicitor appointed that he or she held a current practising certificate and held professional indemnity insurance.

However, despite the fact that solicitors on the independent panel maintained by the DSS had to be eligible to practise law, be appropriately indemnified, and suitably qualified and experienced, it soon became apparent that any solicitor appointed as a decision-making representative to a relevant person should never provide legal services on behalf of that relevant person.

This is the stated position of the DSS – but this ‘well-reasoned position’ wasn’t made clear to all concerned at the outset.

Role envisaged

So, why were practising solicitors appointed to the independent decision-making representative panel in the first place? What role was envisaged by the DSS for the practising solicitor as ‘unthinking flunkey’?

With the benefit of hindsight, it would have made sense to assemble an expert panel of willing and experienced solicitors who could have undertaken work on behalf of court-appointed decision-making representatives and to fund that work in the interest of vulnerable persons where legal aid was not available (as it often isn’t).

Similarly, the issue of remuneration for the work carried out by a decision-making representative for services to a relevant person is equally fraught. If you are remunerated by the DSS, then it may be possible to circumvent the definition of ‘client’ as contained within the Attorneys’ and Solicitors’ Act 1870.

Solicitor and ‘client’

However, if you are remunerated from the assets of the relevant person, as a practising solicitor on behalf of a relevant person, then it is difficult to countenance any circumstances where a relevant person could not be deemed to be a ‘client’, which includes “[any] person who is or may be liable to pay the bill of an attorney or solicitor for any services, fees, costs, charges, or disbursements”.

The Attorneys’ and Solicitors’ Act makes provision for an agreement to be entered into as between a solicitor and a client in respect of fees but, at section 7, expressly provides that: “A provision in any such agreement that the attorney or solicitor shall not be liable for negligence, or that he shall be relieved from any responsibility to which he would otherwise be subject as such attorney or solicitor, shall be wholly void.”

Moreover, section 85 of the Solicitors’ Act 1954 affirms: “To remove doubt, it is hereby declared that the Attorneys’ and Solicitors’ Act 1870 applies, and always applied, in the State.”

Therefore, every solicitor who has been appointed as an independent decision-making representative should keep the circumstances of any individual appointment under continuing review.

Managing monies

As a solicitor decision-making representative, you may wish to give further consideration as to how you have been asked to manage monies on foot of a High Court or Circuit Court order, as having custody, control, and management of an account opened or maintained on behalf of a relevant person could be deemed to be a ‘client account’ within the meaning provided by Solicitors Accounts Regulations 2023 (SI 118 of 2023).

If, in your capacity as a decision-making representative, you engage a third-party solicitor to perform legal services on behalf of a relevant person, what are your obligations to fellow legal professionals?

Any order appointing a decision-making representative expires contemporaneously with the demise of the relevant person. If you engage a colleague to carry out legal work, and you have no means of ensuring that a colleague is paid for legal services, then this creates further professional and ethical concerns.

If the court order appointing a solicitor as a decision-making representative authorises them to take legal action on the relevant person’s behalf, and the relevant person doesn’t have the means to finance this, they must apply for legal aid for the relevant person.

However, the Legal Aid Board may well refuse legal aid under section 28 of the Civil Legal Aid Act 1995 (as amended). In particular, disputes regarding ‘rights and interests in or over land’ (subject to exceptions) will not be considered.

Property rights are often the very rights that need to be vindicated for relevant persons.

Powerlessness

This leaves solicitor decision-making representatives in the impossible position of being unable to use their skills to take action on behalf of vulnerable persons who they have been appointed to assist.

Meanwhile, they are left to try and explain their powerlessness to relevant persons and their families.

In the past, the committee of many such persons was the General Solicitor for Minors and Wards of Court, whose office (and agent solicitors) took whatever legal action was required to successfully vindicate the rights of wards of court, regardless of the cost.

The commencement of the Assisted Decision-Making (Capacity) Act 2015 (as amended) was heralded as a paradigm shift in how the most vulnerable in the State would be supported.

However, when a system is failing the most vulnerable in the State, it takes courage and wisdom from those in positions of responsibility to admit that mistakes have been made in the implementation of the processes supporting the legislation.

And, in the meantime, there are many practising solicitors with considerable experience in acting for vulnerable adults who are ready and willing to be more than an ‘unthinking flunkey’.

Niall Farrell (managing partner at Patrick J Farrell & Company LLP, Newbridge, Co Kildare) and Maria Dillon (Horan & Son, Woodquay, Galway) are members of the Law Society’s Mental Health Law and Capacity Task Force.

Gazette Desk
Gazette.ie is the daily legal news site of the Law Society of Ireland

Copyright © 2026 Law Society Gazette. The Law Society is not responsible for the content of external sites – see our Privacy Policy.