We use cookies to collect and analyse information on site performance and usage to improve and customise your experience, where applicable. Click OK to use our website.

Campaigning solicitor ‘disappointed’ with An Bord Pleanála decision

10 Jul 2020 / environment Print

Campaigning solicitor ‘disappointed’ by An Bord Pleanála decision

Campaigning environmentalist and solicitor Michelle Hayes (pictured) has expressed her disappointment with an An Bord Pleanála decision to allow the demolition of Limerick’s Curragower House.

The 2:1 decision, issued on 3 July, will allow the house to be replaced by a townhouse, apartments and a café.

'Travesty'

Hayes is president of Environmental Trust Ireland and former chair of An Taisce Limerick, and said: “The destruction of the 18th century Georgian building, Curragower House, would be a complete travesty and present an enormous loss to the historic, visual, cultural and architectural heritage of Limerick City and County. Once gone, it’s gone forever”.

An Bord Pleanála (APB), in its decision, referred to the fact that Curragower House is not a protected structure.

Michelle Hayes said that she had called on Limerick City and County Council in April 2019 to list Curragower House.

Ruling

The planning authority’s ruling says that the proposed development “would not seriously injure the visual amenities of the area or the amenity of property in the vicinity, would not adversely affect the character of the protected structure adjoining the site, would be acceptable in terms of pedestrian and traffic safety, and would constitute an acceptable form of development on these zoned lands”.

A planning inspector had previously decided to refuse permission on the grounds that the proposed development was “incongruous … because of siting, scale and bulk”.

The inspector’s report continued: “I would have serious concerns regarding the demolition … the demolition of an existing historic dwelling Curragower House, which contributes to the architectural character of the area, would fail to have regard for the intrinsic historic character of Clancy’s Strand.”

Overturned

This assessment was overturned by An Bord Pleanála on foot on an examination of the file, including submissions from third parties and observers.

The board concluded that the existing building on site, which is not a protected structure, presents issues of structural and functional challenge.

Its decision says that its replacement with a “well-conceived design solution providing for new residential accommodation and café unit would constitute an appropriate and sustainable use of the zoned subject site”.

The decision states that the new-build “will not adversely affect a defined character for this area, but will complement the current varied built form with a high-quality modern design and layout”.

Heartened

Appellants and observers may yet pursue a judicial review - Michelle Hayes has urged An Taisce Limerick to continue the work she started.

“Curragower House is still standing – let’s keep it that way,” she said.

Speaking to Gazette.ie, she said she was heartened and encouraged in her battle to save Curragower House by the public support for its retention.

“This building is clearly cherished by the people of Limerick, who have taken this historic and architectural gem to their hearts,” she concluded.

Gazette Desk
Gazette.ie is the daily legal news site of the Law Society of Ireland