We use cookies to collect and analyse information on site performance and usage to improve and customise your experience, where applicable. Click OK to use our website.

Adidas three stripes not infringed by H&M branding, court rules

11 Mar 2020 / IP law Print

Adidas three stripes not infringed by H&M branding

Fashion retailer H&M has defeated Adidas in a long-standing trademark dispute about Adidas’ distinctive three-stripe logo.

A decades-long legal battle was settled before the Hague Court of Appeal with a ruling that the H&M two-stripe block colour logo does not infringe Adidas’ three-stripe emblem.

German sports-giant Adidas has since the 1970s registered several trademarks in Benelux for its famous black and white ‘three-stripe’ logo on sports gear.

The Adidas logo is three equally-sized and equally-spaced vertical, parallel stripes.

Parallel stripes

In 1997, Adidas brought an infringement case against H&M in the Netherlands for their branded sportswear with its two parallel stripes.

The case proceeded through the courts and eventually reached Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU).

H&M lawyers argued that its use of the two stripes was a decorative use of a common pattern rather than a trademark.

The CJEU considered whether generic patterns were relevant when “assessing the scope of protection of a trademark that is inherently non-distinctive or descriptive, but registrable as a result of distinctiveness acquired through use”.

Similarity

The CJEU ruled in favour of Adidas but the Hague Court of Appeal has now decided that the similarity between the three-stripe and two-stripe logos was only “to a low degree on the basis that they displayed a different number of stripes, spacing width and overall image”.

Consumer surveys presented in court showed that only ten per cent of buyers would potentially confuse the two brands.

Well-known trademarks have higher protection thanks to consumer recognition market awareness but their very distinctiveness mitigates against confusion and allows for more freedom for designers

Gazette Desk
Gazette.ie is the daily legal news site of the Law Society of Ireland