Ireland is being urged to build a permanent defence against disinformation, foreign interference, and AI-generated deepfakes to safeguard its democratic integrity. Mark McDermott reports
A major discussion paper on election security warns that, while Ireland has made significant progress in protecting its electoral system, the pace of technological change is creating new vulnerabilities that regulation alone cannot solve.
Safeguarding Irish Elections (published by the Law Society’s Centre for Justice and Law Reform) argues that social-media algorithms, anonymous online networks, and increasingly sophisticated AI tools are transforming the way political information is being created, distributed, and consumed.
Its central message is stark: safeguarding future elections will require a coordinated, whole-of-society response involving Government agencies, regulators, technology companies, researchers, educational institutions – and citizens themselves.
The warning comes as advances in generative AI have dramatically lowered the barriers to creating highly convincing fake images, videos, and audio recordings that can be used to mislead voters, damage reputations, and distort political debate.
While misinformation and disinformation have long existed in politics, the report notes that digital technologies have enabled false narratives to spread at unprecedented speed and scale.
The concern is no longer simply about inaccurate information, but about coordinated campaigns designed to manipulate public opinion and undermine trust in democratic institutions.
Four threat areas
The report focuses on four key areas: misinformation, disinformation, foreign information manipulation and interference (FIMI), and AI-generated content.
Although evidence directly linking online disinformation to electoral outcomes remains limited, the report points to increasing evidence that false and misleading content contributes to political polarisation, weakens confidence in public institutions, and erodes trust in democratic processes.
Recent elections across Europe, including in Ireland, have demonstrated how both domestic and foreign actors can exploit online platforms to circulate misleading content, target candidates, and cast doubt on election results.
The challenge is not just about polling day – researchers and policymakers are increasingly worried about the impact of sustained online manipulation, where repeated exposure to inaccurate or misleading information gradually corrodes confidence in political systems, electoral authorities, and traditional media.
The report argues that democratic legitimacy ultimately depends on voters having access to reliable information. When citizens lose confidence in the information environment, the integrity of the wider electoral process also comes under pressure.
Moreover, if hostility, intimidation, and coordinated online attacks deter prospective candidates, the diversity and representativeness of public institutions can suffer. The report suggests that representative democracy is weakened when public participation comes at too high a personal cost.
Ireland’s response
Despite these concerns, the paper paints a broadly positive picture of Ireland’s recent regulatory reforms. The creation of An Coimisiún Toghcháin, Ireland’s independent electoral commission, is identified as a significant advancement in protecting election integrity.
Alongside it, Coimisiún na Meán has emerged as a central regulator in the oversight of online safety and media regulation, and the establishment of Ireland’s AI Office is an important development.
These reforms have created what the paper describes as a strong foundation for addressing digital threats. Yet significant gaps remain. The effectiveness of many measures ultimately depends on whether technology companies implement them in a meaningful and consistent way.
Questions also remain around regulatory coordination, political advertising, access to platform data, election monitoring, and the balance between combating harmful content and protecting freedom of expression.
Public trust
One of the report’s strongest conclusions is that election protection cannot rely solely on content moderation. Instead, it advocates a broad resilience-based approach focused on building public trust and strengthening institutions.
It recommends the creation of a permanent election integrity coordination mechanism. Such a body would coordinate information sharing, monitor emerging threats, and support rapid responses during election periods.
The report also calls for stronger cooperation between regulators overseeing elections, online platforms, and political finance rules.
Another key proposal is the creation of an election information partnership framework to improve the dissemination of trusted electoral information through collaborations involving fact-checkers, universities, civil society organisations, and public-service media.
Ultimately, the report concludes that no regulatory structure can succeed without an informed public. Among its most significant recommendations is a major expansion of media-literacy programmes across schools, colleges, and wider society.
Democratic resilience depends upon citizens being equipped to recognise manipulation, question dubious claims, and identify trustworthy sources of information.
As AI-generated content becomes more sophisticated and foreign interference tactics become more complex, that capability will become increasingly important, the authors say.
Protecting future elections, the report concludes, will require vigilance, cooperation and sustained investment in public trust. In an era when a convincing fake video can circle the globe in minutes, preserving confidence in democracy is as important as protecting the ballot box itself.
Mark McDermott is editor of the Law Society Gazette.
KEY RECOMMENDATIONS